.png)
When you're crafting a family history, it can be tough to decide what to do with unproven family stories, especially if they're sensitive or controversial. Should you include them, even when there’s no clear evidence?
Let’s break down how to handle these tricky situations without compromising the integrity of your genealogy project.
The Challenge of Unproven Family Stories
Have you ever heard a captivating family story but struggled to find any solid proof? Maybe your ancestor lived an adventurous life, and according to family lore, they met a dramatic end. You’ve searched every document, scanned newspaper articles, and combed through family letters, but the details remain fuzzy. What do you do with these stories when you're writing about your ancestors?
It’s a common problem for family historians. We all want to share our ancestors’ stories, but when those stories rely more on speculation than fact, it’s hard to know what to include.
↪️ Do you want to write a family history book?
Grab your copy of this FREE Writing Guide:
Use Your Judgment (And Be Kind)
When deciding whether to include unproven family stories, exercise good judgment. You want to honor your ancestors, but that doesn’t mean repeating every rumor without question. Caroline Baxter, a family history writer I’ve interviewed, put it well: “You’re the writer. You need to use your judgment on what you're going to do.”
Here’s a rule of thumb: if a story, even without proof, significantly impacted your ancestor's life, it might belong in your family history. However, if it’s just a passing rumor that hasn’t been confirmed or debunked, consider leaving it out of the main narrative.
This video is part of tutorials on the Write Your Family History YouTube Channel
Where to Include Sensitive Information
If you do decide to include an unproven story, you have a few options for how to present it:
The Main Storyline: If the rumor or story had a real impact on your ancestor’s life and can’t be ignored, it may deserve a place in the main body of your story. For example, if your ancestor was dogged by a rumor that shaped how others treated them, it might be necessary to include it for context.
The Appendix: Personally, I prefer placing unproven stories in the appendix. This is where I document family legends, suspicions, or research questions that haven’t yet been resolved. Including it in the appendix signals that the story is part of the family narrative but hasn’t been confirmed. It also opens the door for future researchers to explore and possibly solve the mystery.
Debunking Family Legends
Sometimes, stories get passed down that simply don’t add up. Take my ancestor, Joseph Geißler. There’s a family tale that he was shot outside the Columbus Barracks because he didn’t understand the command "Halt!" Being German, the story goes, he didn’t know what the word meant. But when I looked deeper, I found that "halt" is a word German speakers are familiar with. The story unraveled from there.
In cases like this, I debunk the legend in the appendix, explaining why it likely isn’t true. It’s important to gently correct these inaccuracies while still respecting the fact that they are part of the family lore.
Handling Sensitive Topics: When There’s No Proof
Now, what if the unproven family story involves something more sensitive, like suicide, scandal, or another challenging subject? If you suspect something but have no proof, it’s better to tread carefully. Here are a few tips:
Be Gentle: Address these topics with compassion and sensitivity. If the rumor affected your family, mention it in a way that acknowledges its impact without passing judgment.
State the Facts (or Lack Thereof): It’s okay to say, “We don’t have proof, but this is a story that’s been told.” Make sure your readers understand that it’s unverified, which is why it’s not in the main narrative.
Encourage Future Research: When possible, use these stories as an invitation for future generations to investigate further. Maybe one day, someone will uncover the truth.
How to Handle Unproven Family Stories in Your Own Writing
So, what should you do with the unproven family stories floating around in your family tree? Should you ignore them, address them head-on, or quietly debunk them in the appendix? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but a thoughtful approach will help.
Ask yourself:
Did the story affect your ancestor’s life significantly?
Do you have any evidence to support or refute it?
Would including the story help future researchers?
Remember, family history is about more than just names and dates—it’s about understanding the lives our ancestors lived, even when some of those lives are wrapped in mystery.
Join the Conversation
How do you handle unproven family stories in your research? Do you include them, debunk them, or leave them out? I’d love to hear your thoughts. Let’s have a positive discussion and learn from each other’s experiences!
Ready to Write Your Family History? Head over to the Write Your Family History YouTube channel! There, you’ll find techniques, inspiration, and examples of how others have tackled the challenge of capturing and preserving their ancestors' stories.
