Devon Noel Lee

5 min read

Same-Name Genealogy Brick Wall Research Methodology Explained

Advanced Genealogy Research Methodology Same Name Elimination Strategy

Don't you hate it when your ancestor has a name that many people have in common with him or her? Sometimes you need to research every person with the same name to know when one is your ancestor.

There isn't a name for what I'm about to teach you; however, my friend Amy Johnson Crow says, "This is just good research."

Same-Name Rule Out Genealogy Research Basics

In what I'm calling the Same Name Rule Out Method, you're trying to exclude people who could not possibly be your ancestor, leaving one likely candidate.

You exclude people because:

They are not the right age.
They are not in the right place.
They are not doing the right things.
They are connected to entirely different people through established documentation.

After you finish this research, you will filter down to a handful of possibilities or only one person.

How I Set My Same Name Rule Out Parameters

To find the most likely son of Effingham Townley, who died in 1828 in Elizabethtown, New Jersey, I need to set some boundaries.

First, I'll search the 1830 and 1840 US Census records for heads of households named John. Ideally, these Johns would live in Elizabethtown, New Jersey, but the nation was expanding west at that time, so I won't rule out Johns based on location.

Second, I would include multiple spelling variations of the names John and Townley.

Third, the Johns had to be of a certain age to be Effingham's son.

Watch this research process in action in this video.

Determining a Birth Year For A Brick Wall Ancestor

I consulted his siblings ' documentation to develop a likely birth year of John, son of Effingham. Additionally, I considered the order in which the siblings' names appeared in Effingham Townley's will dated 1828.

In the will of 1828, Effingham's children are listed in the following order: Richard, Abby, John, Jane, and Caleb. Effingham's will also identify a son named William, who is deceased.

Many wills record the names of heirs in birth order. Thus, Richard's birth should likely have occurred before John's, while Caleb's birth occurred after.

Based on information in his death register entry, Richard's birth likely occurred in 1794. Caleb was born in 1805 and 1806, according to documents I've saved to the FamilySearch family tree.

According to William's gravestone, he died in 1827, a year before Effingham. The stone also indicated that his birth year was about 1796

At this time, little evidence exists for Abby and Jane, other than their appearance on their father's will. However, in the FamilySearch online tree, their undocumented birth years are 1798 and 1802, respectively.

For the moment, I will consider these birth years to help isolate a likely year that John was born.

After considering John's siblings' birth order from the will and the likely birth years, I suspect his birth falls between 1798 and 1802.

With this age range in mind, I can consult the 1830 census.

If you want your own genealogy research plan template, get a copy of my Research Plan Template, print it out, or use it online.

Searching for Potential Candidates to Rule Out or In

Using the Ancestry.com 1830 US Census database, I cast a wide net for John Townleys. I came up with a list of about 20-25 names, which you can see in the Updated Research Plan.

I focused on any John Townleys in the 20-29 and 30-39 age ranges.

In the video Same Named Persons in Genealogy Research: Which One is My Ancestor? and research plan, I demonstrated my decision-making process for why I ruled out each possibility.

When you're analyzing the possibilities, make sure you know the question you're asking to ensure you make the correct conclusions.

I mistakenly compared the 1830 John Townleys to the 1840 Census record. I found for my direct ancestor. Instead, I needed to focus on which John Townley could be Effingham's son.

After I determined which one could be Effingham's son, I could compare the 1830 and 1840 census entries.

If you make a mistake, no worries. Instead, stop and reevaluate your work.

↪️ Are you struggling to break through your brick walls?

Grab your copy of this FREE Brick Wall Busting Guide:

GET YOUR FREE Genealogy Brick Wall Guide

Consult More Than One Record Set in Same Name Rule Out Analysis

If you only rely on one record set, you might not be confident in your results. So, for my research, I layered land records alongside census records.

Land records have the added value of including spouses in many transactions. For example, knowing the spouses can help separate men of the same name in the same place.

In the video and research notes, I featured the John or Jonathan Townleys in Essex County, New Jersey land records. Thankfully, only one John has a relationship with Effingham Townley, and his wife's name was not included. The other four men could not be Effingham's son.

Applying Occam's Razor to Genealogy Theories

Ultimately, I had two possible Johns who could be Effingham's son.

It's time to apply a little logic to our conclusions, in this case, Occam's Razor.

Occam's Razor said, "The simplest explanation is likely the most accurate."

In genealogy, Occam's Razor doesn't always apply. However, use this theory first until you have evidence that disproves that theory.

Choose the closest if you have two men of the right age to be a relative. Of the two potential sons of Effingham, one lived in Elizabethtown, New Jersey, in 1830, while the other lived in New York City Ward 11.

Since the John in Elizabethtown, New Jersey, would be living in the same town as Effingham's sons Richard and Caleb, the simplest explanation is that John is Effingham's son.

I Solved My Genealogy Brick Wall

Leveraging the power of the Same Name Rule Out Method to my genealogy brick wall research, along with all of the other research, I'm confident I have broken through my barriers. Now, all I have to do is write up my final genealogy conclusions.

UPDATED Genealogy Research Notes - Click the link to view and comment on the notes I've gathered thus far.